Ranking Every Song On Tate McRae's So Close

Ranking Every Song on Tate McRae's So Close

Tate McRae's So Close EP isn't just a collection of songs; it's a journey. A sonic exploration of heartbreak, longing, and the messy complexities of young love. Released in 2022, the EP solidified McRae's position as a rising star in the pop world, showcasing her undeniable vocal talent and songwriting prowess. This deep dive analyzes each track, ultimately ranking them based on lyrical depth, production quality, and overall impact. Prepare for a passionate discussion of one of pop's most promising young voices!

Analyzing the So Close Tracklist: A Song-by-Song Breakdown

Before we dive into the rankings, let's break down each song individually. Understanding the nuances of each track is crucial to appreciating their placement in the overall hierarchy.

1. she's all i wanna be:

This isn't just an opener; it's a statement. "she's all i wanna be" immediately establishes McRae's signature blend of vulnerable lyrics and powerful vocals. The production is sleek and modern, perfectly complementing the song's melancholic yet empowering theme. The lyrics paint a vivid picture of longing and admiration, exploring the complicated emotions of wanting to be like someone you admire, especially when that someone is romantically involved with the person you desire. Key takeaway: A strong opening that sets the emotional tone for the entire EP.

2. stupid:

"stupid" is a raw, unfiltered expression of regret and self-blame. McRae's vocal performance here is exceptional, conveying the full weight of her emotional turmoil. The production is minimalist, allowing the lyrics and vocals to take center stage. This track masterfully captures the frustration and self-awareness that often accompany a relationship's demise. Key takeaway: A brutally honest and emotionally resonant song.

3. so close:

The title track, "so close," is arguably the most emotionally charged song on the EP. The lyrics describe the agonizing nearness of a lost love, the frustrating proximity to reconciliation, and the heartbreaking reality of distance. The production cleverly builds tension, mirroring the emotional turmoil described in the lyrics. The subtle use of instrumentation adds layers of depth and emotion without overpowering McRae's voice. Key takeaway: A poignant exploration of heartbreak and longing.

4. what would you do?

This song shifts the emotional landscape slightly, delving into the hypothetical scenario of a renewed connection. "what would you do?" is a questioning track, exploring the uncertainty and hesitation that accompany such a prospect. The production maintains a similar sleekness to other tracks, yet introduces a slightly more upbeat tempo, reflecting the glimmer of hope within the lyrics. Key takeaway: A nuanced exploration of hope amidst uncertainty.

5. feel like shit:

The EP's raw nerve. This isn't just a song; it's a visceral experience. "feel like shit" embraces the rawness of heartbreak without apology. The lyrics are direct, unfiltered, and relatable, conveying the deep pain and self-loathing that often accompany a difficult breakup. The production is stripped back, letting the pain in McRae's voice take center stage. Key takeaway: An emotionally powerful and brutally honest track that resonates with anyone who has experienced significant heartbreak.

6. don't be a bad friend:

Compared to the intensely emotional tracks that surround it, "don't be a bad friend" provides a softer, more contemplative atmosphere. It explores the complexities of friendship and loyalty in the wake of a romantic relationship's end. While not as intense emotionally, it offers an important counterpoint to the EP's prevailing themes of heartbreak. The production is mellow and reflective, perfectly complementing the song's introspective lyrics. Key takeaway: A needed moment of reflection and nuance.

Ranking the Songs: A Subjective but Informed Opinion

Now comes the challenging part: ranking these exceptional songs against each other. This ranking is based on a combination of lyrical depth, production quality, and overall impact, acknowledging that musical taste is inherently subjective.

Tier 1: The Standouts

1. "feel like shit": This song transcends typical pop heartbreak anthems. Its rawness, honesty, and emotional impact place it at the top of the list. The sheer vulnerability in McRae's delivery is captivating.

2. "so close": The title track delivers a powerful punch. The lyrical depth, coupled with the emotionally intelligent production, creates a truly unforgettable listening experience. It’s a masterclass in capturing heartbreak's intensity.

3. "stupid": The raw emotion and self-awareness in "stupid" make it a standout track. Its minimalist production perfectly complements the intensity of the lyrics and McRae’s vocal performance.

Tier 2: Exceptional Tracks

4. "she's all i wanna be": A strong opener that sets the tone, this song showcases McRae's songwriting ability and vocal control. While slightly less emotionally intense than the top tier, its quality is undeniable.

5. "what would you do?": This song offers a subtle shift in tone, introducing a glimmer of hope amidst the prevailing heartache. It’s a well-crafted piece that adds valuable nuance to the overall narrative.

Tier 3: Solid Additions

6. "don't be a bad friend": While not as emotionally charged as others, "don't be a bad friend" provides a necessary balance and showcases McRae's versatility as a songwriter. It's a solid track that adds depth to the EP's overall theme.

The So Close EP: A Lasting Impact

Tate McRae's So Close EP is more than just a collection of catchy tunes; it’s a testament to her artistic growth and emotional intelligence. The EP’s success lies in its raw honesty, its vulnerability, and its ability to resonate with listeners on a deeply personal level. Each song contributes to a cohesive narrative, exploring the multifaceted aspects of heartbreak and self-discovery. The production is consistently high-quality, perfectly complementing McRae’s exceptional vocals and songwriting. Ultimately, So Close is a significant contribution to the pop landscape, cementing Tate McRae's status as an artist to watch. The EP's enduring popularity is a testament to its quality and the emotional resonance it holds for listeners. It's an album that stays with you long after the final note fades. This ranking, while subjective, aims to highlight the individual strengths of each song within the context of the EP as a whole. The lasting impact of So Close is undeniable, and its place in McRae’s discography is secure.